Skip to content
Artwork for Oh, What It Seemed to Be Frank Sinatra, Axel Stordahl and His Orchestra

Oh, What It Seemed to Be

Frank Sinatra, Axel Stordahl and His Orchestra

39 sources

39 cited facts

What connects this song

Credits it shares with other songs, each from a cited source. Tap a number or a name.

Open in graph

  1. Released on Columbia, also Chop Suey! (System of a Down), Toxicity (System of a Down) and Pumped Up Kicks (Foster the People)

  2. Written by George David Weiss, also What a Wonderful World (Louis Armstrong), Can’t Help Falling in Love (Elvis Presley) and Mandolinen und Mondschein (Peter Alexander)

  3. Written by Bennie Benjamin, also Wheel of Fortune (Kay Starr), Don’t Let Me Be Misunderstood (Santa Esmeralda) and Lonely Man (Elvis Presley)

  4. Written by Frankie Carle, also Sunrise Serenade (Glenn Miller and His Orchestra) and Georgianna (The Count Basie Orchestra)

Worth knowing

Counted from cited credits on fono.

Credits

All 38 credits
Written by
Bennie Benjamin, Frankie Carle and George David Weiss
Performed by
Artie Baker, Bart Wallace, Benjamin Altman, Bernie Kaufman, Bill Clifton, Elaine Vito Ricci, Eugene Powers, Felix Orlewitz, Frank Sinatra, Harold Micklin, Harry Azen, Harry Feldman, Herbert Winfield, Hyman Dickler, Karl Chlupsa, Leonard Posner, Lyman Vunk, Matty Golizio, Melvin "Red" Solomon, Milt Yaner, Milton Bornstein, Nat Polen, Raoul Polikian, Sam Caplan, Sam Shoobe, Samuel Finkel, Seymour Shaffer, Sid Harris, Sidney Brecher, Theodore Adoff, Walter Hagen, William Pritchard and Wolffe Taninbaum
Part of
Oh! What It Seemed to Be / Day by Day
Released on
Columbia

Connected by credits

Other songs that share a producer, writer, studio or label with this one.

Elsewhere

Sources (39)

Every fact on this page comes from one of these sources.

  1. 1MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Artie Baker

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Artie Baker

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  2. 2MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Bart Wallace

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Bart Wallace

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  3. 3MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Benjamin Altman

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Benjamin Altman

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  4. 4MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Bernie Kaufman

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Bernie Kaufman

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  5. 5MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Bill Clifton

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Bill Clifton

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  6. 6MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Elaine Vito Ricci

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Elaine Vito Ricci

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  7. 7MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Eugene Powers

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Eugene Powers

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  8. 8MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Felix Orlewitz

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Felix Orlewitz

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  9. 9MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Frank Sinatra

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Frank Sinatra

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  10. 10MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Harold Micklin

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Harold Micklin

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  11. 11MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Harry Azen

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Harry Azen

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  12. 12MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Harry Feldman

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Harry Feldman

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  13. 13MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Herbert Winfield

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Herbert Winfield

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  14. 14MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Hyman Dickler

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Hyman Dickler

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  15. 15MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Karl Chlupsa

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Karl Chlupsa

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  16. 16MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Leonard Posner

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Leonard Posner

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  17. 17MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Lyman Vunk

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Lyman Vunk

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  18. 18MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Matty Golizio

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Matty Golizio

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  19. 19MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Melvin "Red" Solomon

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Melvin "Red" Solomon

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  20. 20MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Milt Yaner

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Milt Yaner

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  21. 21MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Milton Bornstein

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Milton Bornstein

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  22. 22MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Nat Polen

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Nat Polen

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  23. 23MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Raoul Polikian

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Raoul Polikian

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  24. 24MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Sam Caplan

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Sam Caplan

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  25. 25MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Sam Shoobe

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Sam Shoobe

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  26. 26MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Samuel Finkel

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Samuel Finkel

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  27. 27MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Seymour Shaffer

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Seymour Shaffer

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  28. 28MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Sid Harris

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Sid Harris

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  29. 29MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Sidney Brecher

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Sidney Brecher

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  30. 30MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Theodore Adoff

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Theodore Adoff

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  31. 31MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Walter Hagen

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Walter Hagen

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  32. 32MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by William Pritchard

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by William Pritchard

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  33. 33MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Wolffe Taninbaum

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was performed by Wolffe Taninbaum

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  34. 34MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was written by Bennie Benjamin

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was written by Bennie Benjamin

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  35. 35MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was written by Frankie Carle

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was written by Frankie Carle

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  36. 36MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was written by George David Weiss

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was written by George David Weiss

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  37. 37MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be is part of the release Oh! What It Seemed to Be / Day by Day

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be is part of the release Oh! What It Seemed to Be / Day by Day

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  38. 38MusicBrainz Columbia is the label of the song Oh, What It Seemed to Be

    Columbia is the label of the song Oh, What It Seemed to Be

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026

  39. 39MusicBrainz Oh, What It Seemed to Be was released on 1946

    Oh, What It Seemed to Be was released on 1946

    MusicBrainz

    MusicBrainz core data (CC0)Retrieved Sep 30, 2026